Schechter: We’ve hit bottom Part 3

What goes down must go up? According to local economist Jonathan Schechter, all signs indicate Jackson Hole's economy has hit bottom, a precursor for any upward movement.

This week my favorite Jackson Hole economist, Jonathan Schechter, completes his three-part series on why the local economy has hit bottom with a look at taxable sales.

While not nearly as fascinating (to me at least) as his analysis of real estate sales and inches of classified ads in the local newspapers, this week’s article also is a must read. (Unfortunately the Jackson Hole News&Guide doesn’t seem to store back columns for its columnists, but here is a link to my post on the last one, which includes a link to the one on real estate.)

It’s key to read the entire article to fully grasp the context, but for me the most salient takeaways include:

  • “The good news is that total taxable sales have held steady at around $920 million for the past three months, the first time this has happened since sales peaked in 2008. So, while taxable sales may not be growing, at least they seem to have stabilized, the necessary precursor to growth.”
  • “Construction is a different story. A lagging indicator, taxable construction sales continued to grow through the middle of last summer, nearly a year after the rest of the economy started to tank. When it started to fall, though, construction spending went south in a hurry: 40 percent since its peak in January 2009, a compounded average of 3.5 percent per month. And given that building materials represent less than half of a given construction project, it’s hard to describe just how cataclysmic a change this is for the entire building trades industry.”
  • “The good news is that if we ignore construction-related expenditures (which currently account for only 9 percent of the total), overall taxable sales have basically stabilized in the last several months. This is the same sort of thing we see with classified ads and real estate – while things may not be growing yet, at least they’ve stopped declining. This is great news, for it means that every piece of timely and meaningful data I’ve examined suggests our economic decline has stabilized.”

I’m looking forward to a promised article devoted entirely to the “building trades implosion” that continues to be a significant drag on the overall economy of Jackson Hole. I’ll keep you posted!

Jackson Hole’s clearest economic voice: We’ve hit bottom

He correctly predicted real estate sales in Teton County, Wyoming, would hit bottom during the fourth quarter of 2009. In his most recent column in the Jackson Hole News&Guide, Jonathan Schechter hypothesizes the overall local economy hit bottom in recent weeks.

“The bleeding has been stanched,” writes Schechter, an economist who writes biweekly.

As I’ve written before, Schechter is a must read for anyone interested in the future of this community. And few people have been as proactive in preserving the natural assets that continue to define quality of life in the Greater Yellowstone Ecosystem, as proven by his nonprofit 1% for the Tetons.

Why does he think we’ve hit bottom? The answer is in the Classifieds section of the newspaper. Highlights of the column, headlined “Ad inches add up to positive news,” include:

  • “When judged by help-wanted ads, our economy seems to have crested in the winter of 2007-08. The number of ads started slowing in the spring of 2008 (around the time Bear Stearns collapsed). After that, things went into an 18-month free fall, finally stabilizing late last year, albeit at a record-low level.”
  • “Total newspaper pages and help-wanted ad inches are still below where they were a year ago, and way below where they were at their peak. However, starting in October or so, the tide seems to have turned, and at a minimum, the rate of decline has flattened out. “
  • “Whether growth will occur anytime soon is anyone’s guess, but judging by newspaper advertising, it does seem that the hypothesis is true, and the local economy has hit bottom.”

Additionally, Schechter looks closely at the available rental properties to support his hypothesis. He promises his next column, due April 7, will address the same topic with a different set of data. Be sure to pick up a hard copy or read it online.

Schechter: JH should be green model

The Jackson Hole News&Guide has at least two real estate related stories this week – one on foreclosures and another an update on the Jedediah’s House of Sourdough story I mentioned on Monday.

Neither story is online but both deserve comment and I’ll try to follow up later this week. But if you only have time for one piece in the weekly, as usual go straight to economist Jonathan Schechter’s column, which is online.

Schechter’s writing, whether you accept his theories and conclusions or not, is must read for anyone interested in the future of this valley. This week he continues to beat the “sustainability” drum and repeats his call for the Jackson Hole community to become “the world’s first certified green resort community.”

While his topic is rarely specifically Jackson Hole real estate, his material offers a fundamental and invaluable understanding of the dynamics that drive regional values.